Sign in or 

| Immunity | Name | Merge | Finish | Total Votes |
| Danielle DiLorenzo | Russell Hantz Survivor: Samoa & Heroes vs. Villains | Rattana | 1st Voted Out 1st Jury Member | 9 |
| Benjamin "Coach" Wade | Stephenie LaGrossa Survivor: Palau & Guatemala & Heroes vs. Villains | 2nd Voted Out 2nd Jury Member | 6 | |
| Tom Westman | Yau-Man Chan Survivor: Fiji & Micronesia | 3rd Voted Out 3rd Jury Member | 7 | |
| Sierra Reed | Benjamin "Coach" Wade Survivor: Tocantins & Heroes vs. Villains | 4th Voted Out 4th Jury Member | 5 | |
| Parvati Shallow | Sierra Reed Survivor: Tocantins | 5th Voted Out 5th Jury Member | 7 | |
| Amanda Kimmel | Parvati Shallow Survivor: Cook Islands & Micronesia & Heroes vs. Villains | 6th Voted Out 6th Jury Member | 5 | |
| Lydia Morales | Tom Westman Survivor: Palau & Heroes vs. Villains | 7th Voted Out 7th Jury Member | 3 | |
| Danielle DiLorenzo | Lydia Morales Survivor: Guatemala | 8th Voted Out 8th Jury Member | 1 | |
| Amanda Kimmel Survivor: China & Micronesia & Heroes vs. Villains | | 1 | ||
| Danielle DiLorenzo Survivor: Panama & Heroes vs. Villains | | 2 |
| Voter: | Voted for: |
| Russell Hantz | Amanda Kimmel |
| Stephenie LaGrossa | |
| Yau-Man Chan | Danielle Dilorenzo |
| Benjamin "Coach" Wade | Danielle DiLorenzo |
| Sierra Reed | Amanda Kimmel |
| Parvati Shallow | |
| Tom Westman | |
| Lydia Morales | Danielle DiLorenzo |
| | Merged Tribe | |||||||
| Episode #: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | |
| Eliminated: | Russell 9/10 Votes | Stephenie 5/9 Votes | Yau-Man 7/8 Votes | Coach 5/7 Votes | Sierra 4/6 Votes | Parvati 4/5 Votes | Tom 3/4 Votes | Lydia 1 Vote |
| Voter | Vote | |||||||
| Amanda | Russell | Stephenie | Yau-Man | Coach | Sierra | Parvati | Tom | |
| Danielle | Russell | Stephenie | Yau-Man | Coach | Sierra | Parvati | Tom | Lydia |
| Lydia | Russell | Stephenie | Yau-Man | Coach | Sierra | Parvati | Tom | |
| Tom | Russell | Stephenie | Yau-Man | Coach | Sierra | Parvati | ? | |
| Parvati | Russell | Sierra | Yau-Man | ? | ? | ? | ||
| Sierra | Russell | Stephenie | Yau-Man | Coach | Danielle | |||
| Coach | Russell | Sierra | Yau-Man | Danielle | ||||
| Yau-Man | Russell | Parvati | Amanda | |||||
| Stephenie | Russell | Sierra | ||||||
| Russell | Stephenie | |||||||