| Contestant | Original Tribe | Absorbed Tribe | Merged Tribe | Finish | Total Votes |
Alicia Calaway 35, New York City, NY Survivor:Australian Outback | Chapera |
|
| 1st Voted Out Day 3 | 2 |
Tom Buchanan 48, Williamsburg, KY Survivor: Africa | Chapera |
|
| 2nd Voted Out Day 6 | 4 |
Jerri Manthey 33, Los Angeles, CA Survivor: Australian Outback | Saboga |
|
| 3rd Voted Out Day 9 | 5 |
Richard Hatch 42, Middletown, RI Survivor: Borneo | Mogo Mogo |
|
| 4th Voted Out Day 12 | 5 |
Amber Brkich 25, Beaver, PA Survivor: Australian Outback | Chapera | Chapera |
| 5th Voted Out Day 15 | 8 |
Rupert Boneham 39, Indianapolis Survivor: Pearl Islands | Saboga | Saboga |
| 6th Voted Out Day 17 | 6 |
Rudy Boesch 75, Virginia Beach, VA Survivor: Borneo | Saboga | Saboga |
| 7th Voted Out Day 19 | 5 |
Lex van den Berghe 40, Santa Cruz, CA Survivor: Africa | Mogo Mogo | Saboga |
| 8th Voted Out Day 21 | 5 |
Susan Hawk 42, Las Vegas, NV Survivor: Borneo | Chapera | Chapera |
| 9th Voted Out Day 24 | 6 |
Ethan Zohn 30, New York City, NY Survivor: Africa | Saboga | Saboga | | 10th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 27 | 6 |
Tina Wesson 42, Knoxville, TN Survivor: Australian Ouback | Saboga | Saboga | | 11th Voted Out 2nd Jury Member Day 28 | 6 |
Jenna Morasca 22, Bridgeville, PA Survivor: Amazon | Mogo Mogo | Saboga | | 12th Voted Out 3rd Jury Member Day 30 | 4 |
Rob Mariano 27, Canton, MA Survivor: Marquesas | Chapera | Chapera | Chaboga Mogo | 13th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 33 | 13 |
Jenna Lewis 26, Burbank, CA Survivor: Borneo | Saboga | Saboga | | 14th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 36 | 8 |
Rob Cesternino 25, Plainview, NY Survivor: Africa | Chapera | Chapera | | 15th Voted Out 6th Jury Member Day 37 | 4 |
Kathy Vavrick O'Brien 49, Berlington, VT Survivor Marquesas | Mogo Mogo | Chapera | | 16th Voted Out 7th Jury Member Day 38 | 4 |
Colby Donaldson 29, Los Angeles, CA Survivor: Australian Outback | Mogo Mogo | Chapera | |
Runner-Up | 0 |
Shii Ann Huang 29, New York City, NY Survivor: Thailand | Mogo Mogo | Chapera | |
Sole Survivor | 3 |
| Episode Title | Reward | Immunity | Eliminated | Vote | Finish |
| "Here We Go Again!" | None | Mogo Mogo Saboga | Alicia | 2-1-1-1-1 | 1st Voted Out Day 3 |
| "Fight or Flight" | Mogo Mogo | Mogo Mogo Saboga | Tom | 3-2 | 2nd Voted Out Day 6 |
| "What's Right or What's Good" | Mogo Mogo | Mogo Mogo Chapera | Jerri | 5-1 | 3rd Voted Out Day 9 |
| "It's Time to Start Playing" | Saboga | Saboga Chapera | Richard | 5-1 | 4th Voted Out Day 12 |
| "I'm Saved" | Chapera | Saboga | Amber | 5-2 | 5th Voted Out Day 15 |
| "I'm in a Hot Pickle" | Chapera | Rupert | 5-2 | 6th Voted Out Day 17 |
| "Too Easy" | Chapera | Rudy | 5-1 | 7th Voted Out Day 19 |
| "In the Middle" | Chapera | Chapera | Lex | 3-2 | 8th Voted Out Day 21 |
| "This Could Save My Life" | Saboga | Sue | 5-1 | 9th Voted Out Day 24 |
"Traitor" |
None | Colby, Kathy |
Ethan |
6-3 | 10th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 27 |
"Outnumbered" | Tina, Rob C, Kathy, Shii Ann | Kathy |
Tina |
4-2-2 | 11th Voted Out 2nd Jury Member Day 28 |
"Making Up Is Hard To Do" | Kathy |
Jenna L |
Jenna M |
4-3 | 12th Voted Out 3rd Jury Member Day 30 |
"What To Do?" | Rob M [Rob C] | Jenna L |
Rob M |
4-2 | 13th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 33 |
"Time to Go" | Jenna L [Rob C] |
Shii Ann |
Jenna L |
4-1 | 14th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 36 |
"The Way to Win" |
None |
Colby |
Rob C |
3-1 | 15th Voted Out 6th Jury Member Day 37 |
Colby |
Kathy |
1-0 | 16th Voted Out 7th Jury Member Day 38 |
| "The Reunion" | Jury Vote | Colby | 5-2 | Runner-Up |
| Shii Ann | Sole Survivor |
Episode Summaries:Episode 1: Here We Go Again! - Reward/Immunity Challenge: Each tribe has a raft with a pot of fire on it. The other tribes will try to knock the pot in the water to put it out. The first tribe to lose their fire lost immunity. The tribes cannot splash water to put the fire out.
- Reward: Flint
The tribes were surprised to see how they were divided, and even more surprised to find only a machete and a pot. That didn't stop the strategy though. At Chapera, Amber and Rob C. bonded and formed an alliance with Alicia. At Saboga, Jenna formed an alliance with Jerri and Ethan. At Mogo Mogo, Shii Ann, Kathy, and Colby formed an alliance. Then every tribe quickly worked on the shelter. The next day, Boston Rob furthered himself from the rest of his tribe when he got into an argument with Amber about her work ethic. At Mogo Mogo, Richard acted as the provider by bringing in a lot of coconuts. At Saboga, Jenna became the dictator of what everyone did. The next day at the immunity challenge, Mogo Mogo and Saboga teamed up on Chapera, which made Chapera lose immunity. At camp, the alliance couldn't decide on who to vote for. Amber wanted Boston Rob out, Alicia, wanted Sue out, and Rob C., wanted Tom out. At tribal council, Boston Rob revealed the alliance to Jeff, and Amber told Jeff that Boston Rob was jealous that he wasn't in control. For the vote, Amber voted for Boston Rob, Boston Rob voted for Amber, Rob C. voted for Tom, Alicia voted for Sue, and Sue and Tom voted for Alicia. Alicia was the first person voted out in a 2-1-1-1-1 vote.
Episode 2: Fight or Flight - Reward Challenge: Each tribe will swim out to untie 1 of 5 logs and swim back. After each leg someone will stop going out. Once as all logs are gathered, the tribe will use them to assemble a staircase. First tribe to get everyone up the staircase wins.
- Reward: Blankets and Flint
- Immunity Challenge: Each tribe will move crates out of a boat underwater. Once as the boat rises to the surface, they will bail out the water. After the water is bailed out, they will paddle the boat to shore. First 2 tribes to finish win immunity.
At Chapera, Rob C. knew that Tom and Sue were a dangerous pair, but the only way to vote one of them out was to unite with Rob M. and Amber, who caused so much disfunction at camp. The next day, Saboga became annoyed with Jenna's dictatorship. At the reward challenge, Mogo Mogo won reward. At Mogo Mogo, everybody was happy. Everybody was getting along, Richard was providing food, and Shii Ann had started fire. At Saboga, the tribe planned to vote out Jenna first chance they got. At Chapera, Rob C. master his master plan. He aligned with Rob M. and Amber without the 2 knowing he had aligned with the other one. That night, Jerri was a wreck at Saboga. She complained about being cold, hungry, and thirsty. At Chapera, Rob M. and Amber couldn't stop arguing. The next day, Sue and Tom asked Rob C. to help them vote out Amber, because Rob M. was stronger. At Saboga, the tribe was concerned about Jerri's condition. At Mogo Mogo, no one had any problems. The next day, Mogo Mogo was excited for the challenge. At the immunity challenge, Mogo Mogo arrived first followed by Saboga. Which sent Chapera to tribal council again. Back at camp, Rob M. and Amber wanted to vote each other out, but Rob C. told them to vote out Tom. Sue and Tom were confident that Rob C. was with them. At tribal council, Sue said that Chapera had to start winning challenges. For the vote, Rob M., Rob C., and Amber voted for Tom, while Tom and Sue voted for Amber. Tom became the second person voted out in a 3-2 vote.
Episode 3: What's Right or What's Good - Reward Challenge: Each tribe will build a shelter. The tribe with the best shelter wins.
- Reward: Pillows, blankets, wine, and toiletries.
- Immunity Challenge: Each tribe member will be given a partner. They will be blindfolded. They will make their way through a maze to the center. The 1st 2 tribes to have both pairs unite at the center win immunity.
At Chapera, Rob M. and Amber were still arguing. Sue was mad that Tom was voted out instead of Amber.The next day, the tribes were excited about their reward challenge. After the judging, Mogo Mogo earned reward. Mogo Mogo was still the perfect tribe. Mogo Mogo enjoyed their reward, while Chapera was upset that they lost. At Saboga, Jerri was in an emotional turmoil. She wasn't doing well, and the tribe could see that. The next day, Rob M. and Amber woke Rob C. and Sue up with an argument about Amber taking up too much room in the shelter. Rob C. and Sue decided that if they lost immunity again, Amber would go. At Mogo Mogo, Richard started to further himself from his tribe by drinking all of the wine. At Saboga, Jerri got worse while Jenna got bossier. Jerri asked them to vote her off, if Saboga lost immunity. Saboga was concerned about who to vote off if they lost immunity. Jenna being voted off would keep the tribe happy, but Jerri being voted off would be the right thing to do. The next day, Chapera knew they needed immunity. At the challenge, Mogo Mogo won followed by Chapera. Saboga was still undecided on who should go home. At tribal council, Tina said that tonight's vote would be important for the tribe's future. For the vote, Tina, Rudy, Rupert, Ethan, and Jenna L. voted for Jerri, while Jerri voted for Rupert. Jerri was the third person voted out in a 5-1 vote.
Episode 4: It's Time To Start Playing - Reward Challenge: Each person has a suitcase with their name on it. Inside the suitcase are various items. One at a time, each person will ask another if they have a certain item. If they match up items they get a point. The tribe with the most matches at the end wins reward.
- Reward: Survivor Bathroom, which includes a shower, toilet, toothpaste, mouthwash, toothbrushes, and shampoo.
- Immunity Challenge: One person will be the caller for their tribe. They will direct their tribe mates to find15 scattered puzzle pieces. When all the pieces are collected, the tribe will assemble the puzzle cube. First 2 tribes to finish win immunity.
Jenna was excited that she was still in the game, but knew she was still in danger. The next day, Chapera wanted to finally win reward. At the challenge, Saboga proved to have the better memory and won reward. At Chapera, the tribe was down after the loss. The tribe was too sad to work. At Mogo Mogo, Richard became further an outcast when he spent too much time alone. The next day, Saboga enjoyed their reward. at Chapera, everybody except Sue was still upset about the loss. Sue got down and worked while the others moped. Sue said she wanted something to happen, so she could vote out the rest of her tribe. At Mogo Mogo, the bond between Colby, Kathy, and Shii Ann strengthened. At Saboga, Jenna tried to reconstruct her alliance with Ethan and possibly bring in Tina. The next day, Chapera knew they had to win immunity. At the challenge, Saboga won followed by Chapera. At Mogo Mogo, Richard was the obvious choice to go. At tribal council, Jenna said that the decision was easy. For the vote, Jenna, Shii Ann, Lex, Kathy, and Colby voted for Richard while Richard voted for Lex. Richard became the fourth person voted out in a 5-1 vote.
Episode 5: I'm Saved - Reward Challenge: Each tribe will build a raft out if a bundle of sticks. They will ride the raft out on the ocean grab the flag and paddle back. First tribe to finish wins reward.
- Reward: Fishing gear
- Immunity Challenge: Each tribe member will walk across a series of balance beams to the other side. They will grab a flag and come back. In the middles there is a fight zone. When 2 member meet there they will try toi knock each other off. Whoever falls first has to leave their flag and go back to the start. First tribe to 21 flags win immunity.
Lex was paranoid about the vote for him, even though he knew it came from Richard. His tribe was starting to get annoyed with him. The next day, the tribes found out they would have to build a raft. Rob C. and Rob M. took control of the building at Chapera. Rupert took control of the building at Saboga. Lex took control of the building at Mogo Mogo. at the challenge, Chapera won the challenge easily, and Saboga barely beat Mogo Mogo. Chapera was excited about their reward. Then it was revealed that the losing tribe, Mogo Mogo, would be absorbed by the other 2 tribes. Chapera got to pick first for winning, and they chose Colby. Saboga picked Lex. Chapera picked Kathy. Saboga picked Jenna M. That left Shii Ann to go with Chapera. At Chapera, Sue and Amber wanted the old Chapera to stick together. but Rob C. and Rob M. talked to old Mogo Mogo members about forming an alliance. At Saboga, Jenna L. was excited about the new members she teamed up with them, and talked about bringing in Tina and Ethan, because everybody would want winners off. The next day, Jenna L. confronted Ethan and Tina about joining with her and the old Mogo Mogo member, and they accepted. They accepted to keep themselves safe, so now they had all the power. They could side with Rudy and Rupert or Jenna M., Jenna L., and Lex. The next day, everybody was excited about the immunity challenge. At the challenge, Saboga won immunity. Back at Chapera, Rob C. and Rob M.(The Robs) made a final 2 pact. They knew they could either go with Amber and Sue or Kathy, Shii Ann, and Colby. At tribal council, Amber said that Chapera wasn't a strong enough tribe. For the vote, Rob C, Rob M, Shii Ann, Kathy, and Colby voted for Amber, while Sue and Amber voted for Shii Ann. Amber became the fifth person vote out in a 5-2 vote.
Episode 6: I'm In a Hot Pickle - Reward/Immunity Challenge: One at a time each tribe member will try to catapult a food item into a basket. 1st tribe to get in all food items win reward and immunity.
- Reward: All the food items in the basket and kebabs.
Sue knew she was in trouble when Amber was voted out. She confronted the Robs about them betraying her and Amber. They just got even more mad at Sue. The next day. The tribes were hoping for a reward challenge, but were surprised to find no tree mail. At Saboga, the alliance of Jenna L, Jenna M, Tina, Lex, and Ethan talked about who to vote out first., Rudy or Rupert. At Chapera, the original Mogo Mogo members were still worried about their place in the tribe. Sue confronted them and talked about forming an alliance against the Robs. The Mogo Mogo members immediately told the Robs, which made them angry. They told sue that any chance she had of staying was gone. The next day, the tribes found that they would be playing for reward and immunity. Chapera barely beat Saboga. A disappointed Saboga returned to camp sad and empty-handed. At Chapera, the bond between the Robs and the Mogo Mogo members strengthened, while the distance between Sue and the rest of the tribe increased. At Saboga, the alliance was still unsure on who to vote out. Rudy and Rupert thought that they were still tight with Ethan and Tina, and told them to vote off Jenna L with them. At tribal council, Rupert said that the original Saboga was staying strong. For the vote, Jenna L, Jenna M, Tina , Lex, and Ethan voted for Rupert, while Rupert and Rudy voted for Jenna L. Rupert was the sixth person voted out in a 5-2 vote.
Episode 7: Too Easy - Reward/Immunity Challenge: Each tribe will start out on a platform. One at a time they will swim out and retrieve puzzle pieces. They will then use the ouzzle pieces to form a puzzle boat. They will then paddle to shore. One tribe member will then run into the jungle and cut a rope. That will release a tribe flag and 2 more paddles which they will untie. They will run back and paddle back to the platform. First tribe back at the platform with all 6 paddles and their tribe flag wins immunity and reward.
- Reward: A day on a boat with a barbecue and open bar. They will be taken to an island with a waterfall.
Rudy felt betrayed by his tribe. He knew he was next to go. The next day, Sue was still uncomfortable with her tribe. She tried to reform the Chapera bond by telling the Robs that the Mogo Mogo members would stay together. At Saboga, Rudy told Ethan and Lex, what Jenna L was getting too much power. At Chapera, Kathy and Shii Ann made a Final 2 pact. At Saboga Ethan and Tina did the same. As did Lex and Jenna M. The next day, Rudy and Sue were almost certain for going home unless they won immunity. At the challenge, Chapera won immunity when Lex couldn't untie the paddles. At Saboga, Rudy fought for them to keep him over Lex, who lost immunity for the tribe. The Saboga members were unsure on who to vote out. At tribal council, Rudy said that he knew he was gone. For the vote, Jenna L, Jenna M, Tina, Ethan, and Lex voted for Rudy, while Rudy voted for Lex. Rudy became the seventh person voted out in a 5-1 vote.
Episode 8: In The Middle - Reward Challenge: Log Rolling competition. First person to hit the water loses. First tribe to 5 wins reward.
- Reward: Fishing gear, rice, and tarp.
- Immunity Challenge: Each tribe member will use a blow dart to hit a target. Person closest to the center wins 2 arrows for the final round, losers get one arrow. Then they do the same with spears. For the final round, each tribe will chose an archer. the archer who gets closest to the center wins immunity for their tribe.
Saboga was closer with Rudy gone now. The next day, Sue was still on the outs of her tribe and there was nothing he could do. Rob M said that Sue didn't deserve to still be here, but he wa saved by Chapera constantly winning immunity. At Saboga, Jenna L was in a power position when both side were fighting for her vote. Ethan and Tina wanted her to vote out Lex, while Lex and Jenna M wanted her to vote out Tina. Jenna L was undecided on what to do. At the reward challenge, Chapera won reward which increased Saboga's losing streak. Chapera enjoyed their reward while Saboga was crushed with losing repeatedly. The next day, Sue knew she still needed immunity to saty in the game. At the immunity challenge, Rob M easily won against Lex,who had 4 arrows, in the final round. At Saboga, Tina and Ethan were extremely mad at Lex. They told Jenna L they he was their weakest link. At tribal council, Jenna L said that the tribe needed to start winning challenges. For the vote, Ethan, Tina, and Jenna L voted for Lex, while Lex and Jenna M voted for Tina. Lex became the eighth person voted out in a 3-2 vote.
Episode 9: This Could Save My Life - Reward/Immunity Challenge: Each tribe will be asked questions about previous seasons. Each correct answer is worth 1 point. First tribe to 10 points wins reward and immunity.
- Reward: Fruits and Vegetables
Saboga knew they needed to start winning immunity now that they were down to 4. Jenna M knew she was next to go. The next day, Sue and Jenna M were hoping for a merge so they could switch to the opposite tribe.At Chapera, Sue was tired of bring on the outs of her tribe. At Saboga, Jenna L, Tina, and Ethan were close together, but Jenna M was on the outs. Jenna M told Jenna L that if she went to the final 3 with Tina and Ethan, she would be voted out. The next day, Jenna L approached Jenna M and told her that if they went to tribal council, she would try to help Jenna M vote out Tina. At Chapera, Sue told the Robs that at the final 5, the old Mogo Mogo members would stick together. The next day, Sue and Jenna M were still hoping for a merge. They were disappointed with a reward and immunity challenge. Saboga finally broke their losing streak and won immunity and reward. Saboga enjoyed their reward of fruits and vegetables, while sue worried about going home. At tribal council, Sue said she was certain to go home. For the vote, Rob C, Rob M, Kathy, Shii Ann, and Colby voted for Sue, while Sue voted for Shii Ann. Sue became the ninth person voted out in a 5-1 vote.
Episode 10: Traitor - Immunity Challenge: Everybody will hold their breath underwater. The last 2 people of each gender move on. The two of each gender will face head-to-head. They will dive down and untie 10 bouys. First person to release all 10 buoys wins immunity. One person of each gender will win immunity.
Chapera was a happier tribe with Sue gone. The next day, the Robs approached Colby about going to the final 3. At Saboga, Jenna M planned to jump over to the other tribe at the merge. Both tribes were disappointed when there was no merge that day. the next day, the tribes were merged. There was excitement. They were told they were going to move to the old Mogo Mogo beach, where to winning shelter still stood. Then they were given a merge feast. When they got to camp, they decided to combine all the tribe names and call themselves Chaboga Mogo. Jenna M approached Shii Ann about reforming the old Mogo Mogo tribe. Shii Ann took Kathy, Colby, and Jenna M aside, and told them that they would be final 4. They could team up with Jenna L, Tina, and Ethan or Rob C and Rob M. The next day, the tribe members were excited about the first individual immunity challenge. Kathy and Jenna L moved on for the girls, and Ethan and Colby moved on for the guys. Colby and Kathy ended up winning immunity. Back at camp, the Saboga members decided to vote out Rob M, while the Robs decided to vote off Ethan. The Mogo Mogo members were caught in the middle. At tribal council, Kathy said that everybody who wasn't wearing immunity should feel vulnerable. For the vote, Rob M, Rob C, Kathy, Shii Ann, Colby, and Jenna M voted for Ethan, while Ethan, Tina, and Jenna L voted for Rob M. Ethan became the tenth person voted out and the first member of the jury in a 6-3 vote.
Episode 11: Outnumbered - Reward/Immunity Challenge: The tribe will be divided into 2 groups of 4 that will face head-to-head in an obstacle course. The first team to finish wins reward. The winning foursome will then compete head-to-head for immunity. Each person will be given a sliding puzzle with a knife in one piece. They will complete the puzzle so that they can take out the knife. They will chop a rope raising a flag. First person to raise the flag wins immunity and a video from home.
- Reward: Ponchos and letters from home.
Tina and Jenna L knew they were backed into a corner after tribal council. They had no other allies. The next day, Tina and Jenna L both knew they needed to win reward so they would have strength for the immunity challenge. The tribe was surprised when they were going to a reward and immunity challenge. They were excited to find that the winner would get a video from home, and the winning foursome would get letters from home. Tina, Rob C, Kathy, and Shii Ann won the first round, and reward. Kathy went on to win immunity and the video from home, narrowly beating Tina. She was excited to see her family. Back at camp, the Rob C said that Jenna L was more threatening in challenges. Shii Ann came up with a plan. She pulled in the other Mogo Mogo members to vote out Tina, who showed she was a threat in challenges. Colby, Kathy, and Jenna M were on the fence about who to vote out. At tribal council, Tina said that she and Jenna L were on the next 2 to go. For the vote, Kathy, Colby, Jenna M, and Shii Ann voted for Tina, Rob C and Rob M voted for Jenna L, and Tina and Jenna L voted for Rob M. Tina became the eleventh person voted out and the second jury member in a 4-2-2 vote.
Episode 12: Making Up Is Hard To Do - Reward Challenge: Each person will fill out a questionnaire about other tribe mates. They will then try to guess what the tribes said the answer was. Every time they got a correct answer. They could chop someone's rope. 3 chops, and you were out. The last person standing won reward.
- Reward: Power to choose who got what reward at the dinner.
- Immunity Challenge: The survivors have their arm chained to a bucket of water, while they are standing on a stump. If the water falls on them, they are out. Last one standing wins immunity.
The Robs felt betrayed after the Mogo Mogo member had gone against them. The next day, Shii Ann was trying to figure out how to make it up to the Robs. At the reward challenge, Jenna L was first out followed by Rob M, Shii Ann, Rob C, Jenna M, and Colby. Kathy won reward. At the dinner, Kathy took the steak and open bar, she gave Shii Ann the burger and cola, gave Colby the hot dog and orange juice, gave Jenna M the ham and cheese sandwich, gave Rob C the salad, gave Rob M the cold potatoes, and gave Jenna L the rice. Back at camp, the Robs told Jenna M that she was lowest on the Mogo Mogo alliance, and should help them and Jenna L vote off the other 3, but she declined. The next day, Jenna L knew she needed immunity. At the immunity challenge, Jenna L fought hard and won immunity. Back at camp, the Mogo Mogo members made a plan to vote off Rob M. Shii Ann knew how to apologize to the Robs. She pulled them in along with Jenna L to vote off Jenna M. After Jenna M had declined their alliance offer, the Robs were happy to get rid of her. At tribal council, Jenna L said that she'd have to win immunity every challenge to saty in the game. For the vote, Rob C, Rob M, Shii Ann, and Jenna L voted for Jenna M, while Jenna M, Kathy, and Colby voted for Rob M. Jenna M was the twelfth person voted out and the third jury member in a 4-3 vote.
Episode 13: What To Do? - Reward Challenge: Each tribe member's family must eat a disgusting food. The last person to finish the food is out. Last person standing wins reward for their family member.
- Reward: A day at camp with the the tribe member's loved one.
- Immunity Challenge: Each person must make a fire in a bucket. They will then go to the bucket(with a hole in it) on the other side and fill it with water, which will raise the fire. First person to raise the fire high enough to ignite the flame, wins immunity.
Kathy and Colby felt betrayed by Shii Ann. They made a new Final 2 pact. Shii Ann apologized to them and told them that it was to keep the Robs on their good side. The next day, the tribe members were surprised with their loved ones coming. Rob's brother won, and Rob selected Rob C and his mother to share reward with them. At camp, everybody was jealous that the Robs had their family members at camp. Shii Ann, Colby, and Kathy made up. The next day, the Robs made a plan with Shii Ann that if Jenna L won immunity again that they would vote off Kathy. Kathy and Colby wanted Shii Ann to help them vote off Rob M if Jenna L won immunity. Shii Ann was stuck on what to do. The next day, Shii Ann wanted immunity so she could just vote off Jenna L. At the challenge, Jenna L won immunity again. Back at camp, Shii Ann told Jenna L who to vote off. At tribal council, Jenna L said that she would never be safe without the immunity necklace. For the vote, Shii Ann, Jenna L, Kathy, and Colby voted for Rob M, while Rob M and Rob C voted for Kathy. Rob M was the thirteenth person voted out and the fourth jury member in a 4-2 vote.
Episode 14: Time To Go - Reward Challenge: Each tribe member will run through stages of an obstacle course. Last person to finish a stage is eliminated. First person to finish the last stage wins reward.
- Reward: Car and trip to the Survivor Drive-in movies with popcorn, candy, soda, and hot dogs.
- Immunity Challenge: Each person will do a word search containing the 17 previous tribe names. They will then use then intersecting letters to spell out a mystery word. First person to finish the word wins immunity.
Rob C knew he was on the outs. The next day, everybody was excited for the reward challenge. At the reward challenge, the tribe was excited to see that they were playing for a car. Jenna L barely beat Colby to win the car. Jenna L selected Rob C to come with her on reward. When they arrived at the movies, Jeff revealed that Rob C got a car too. Jenna L talked to Rob C about forming a final 2 alliance. BAck at camp, Kathy, Colby, and Shii Ann were discussing what Jenna L and Rob C were talking about. When Rob C and Jenna L got back, Rob C was stuck on what to do. He talked to Shii Ann about voting out the physically threatening Colby if Jenna L won immunity. Shii Ann was worried and immediately told Kathy and Colby that Rob C was untrustworthy. Shii Ann told Jenna L that Rob C was next to go. Jenna L was excited to have a chance to stay. At the immunity challenge, Shii Ann used her brains and won immunity. Back at camp, Shii Ann told Rob C that Jenna L was gone. It was up to Kathy, Colby, and Shii Ann to decide who was going home. At tribal council, Shii Ann said that at this point in the game, trust is the biggest factor. For the vote, Shii Ann, Kathy, Colby, and Rob C voted for Jenna L, while Jenna L voted for Rob C. Jenna L was the fourteenth person voted out and the fifth jury member in a 4-1 Vote.
Finale: The Way To Win - Immunity Challenge: Each person will run through an obstacle course collecting ladder rungs. Once they have all 7 rungs, they will begin assembling the ladder puzzle. They will use the ladder to climb to the top of the platform. First person to climb to the top of the platform win immunity.
Rob C knew he needed immunity to stay in the game. At the immunity challenge, Colby won immunity. Back at camp, Rob C told Colby that Kathy and Shii Ann would stay together, and that Colby should help Rob C vote off Kathy, who was a bigger immunity threat than Shii Ann. Colby was undecided on what to do. At tribal council, Rob C said that the game could go any way at any point. For the vote, Colby, Kathy, and Shii Ann voted for Rob C, while Rob C voted for Kathy. Rob C became the fifteenth person voted out and the sixth jury member in a 3-1 vote.
- Immunity Challenge: Each person will have one hand on the immunity idol and both feet on a wooden pole. If their other hand touches the idol, or their feet come off the pole, they are out. Last one left wins immunity.
Colby talked to Kathy about their final 2 pact She said that she had one with him and Shii Ann. The next morning, the tribes woke up early. They went to an island where the torches of their fallen tribe mates stood. As they would pass by the torches, they would reflect on that person's time on the island. After that, they would go to their final immunity challenge. Many emotional moments were brought up, especially at Jenna M's torch, which Shii Ann called the hardest vote she ever had to make. At the immunity challenge, Shii Ann dropped out first, followed by Kathy. Colby won his most important immunity challenge. Back at camp, Colby told Shii Ann and Kathy that he would make this decision on his own, and they shouldn't plead their case to him. Colby had a final 2 pact with Kathy, but she was more threatening in a jury than Shii Ann. Shii Ann had rubbed many people the wrong way, but if he took her, people might think he took the easy way out. At tribal council, Colby said this would be his hardest vote ever. For the vote, Colby voted for Kathy. Kathy was the sixteenth person voted out and the seventh jury member with Colby's vote.
Colby and Shii Ann were excited ot have come this far, but were sad that Kathy was gone. Colby and Shii Ann talked about their adventure for the rest of the day. Before they left for tribal council, they burned their camp. At tribal council, Shii Ann said that this game took strategy, and that they shouldn't vote for Colby, because Shii Ann voted them out. Colby said he played a loyal game and followed his alliances to the end. Rob M asked each of them how they grew. Kathy asked nothing of Shii Ann, and asked Colby what the advantage of bringing Shii Ann to the end was. Ethan asked Shii Ann what her boldest strategic move was, and asked Colby what his lowest moment was. Rob C asked both of them who their closest friend was. Jenna L asked Shii Ann what her favorite part of the game was, and asked Colby who he admired most on the island. Tina asked both of them to use one word to describe their game. Jenna M berated Shii Ann for betraying Jenna M, and asked nothing of Colby. For the vote, Tina, Ethan, Rob C, Kathy, and Jenna L voted for Shii Ann, while Jenna M and Rob M voted for Colby. Shii Ann became the winner of Survivor All-Stars in a 5-2 vote.
Voting History
| Original Tribe | Absorbed Tribe | Merged Tribe |
| Episode #: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | Finale |
| Eliminated: | Alicia 2/6 Votes | Tom 3/5 Votes | Jerri 5/6 Votes | Richard 5/6 Votes | Amber 5/7 Votes | Rupert 5/7 Votes | Rudy 5/6 Votes | Lex 3/5 Votes | Sue 5/6 Votes | Ethan 6/9 Votes | Tina 4/8 Votes | Jenna M 4/7 Votes | Rob M 4/6 Votes | Jenna L 4/5 Votes | Rob C 3/4 Votes | Kathy 1 Vote | Colby 2/7 Votes | Shii Ann 5/7 Votes |
| Placing | 18th | 17th | 16th | 15th | 14th | 13th | 12th | 11th | 10th | 9th | 8th | 7th | 6th | 5th | 4th | 3rd | 2nd | 1st |
| Voter | Votes |
| Shii Ann |
|
|
| Richard | Amber |
|
|
| Sue | Ethan | Tina | Jenna M | Rob M | Jenna L | Rob C |
| Jury Vote |
| Colby |
|
|
| Richard | Amber |
|
|
| Sue | Ethan | Tina | Rob M | Rob M | Jenna L | Rob C | Kathy |
| Kathy |
|
|
| Richard | Amber |
|
|
| Sue | Ethan | Tina | Rob M | Rob M | Jenna L | Rob C |
|
| Shii Ann |
| Rob C | Tom | Tom |
|
| Amber |
|
|
| Sue | Ethan | Jenna L | Jenna M | Kathy | Jenna L | Kathy |
|
| Shii Ann |
| Jenna L |
|
| Jerri |
|
| Rupert | Rudy | Lex | | Rob M | Rob M | Jenna M | Rob M | Rob C |
|
|
| Shii Ann |
| Rob M | Amber | Tom |
|
| Amber |
|
|
| Sue | Ethan | Jenna L | Jenna M | Kathy |
|
|
| Colby |
|
| Jenna M |
|
|
| Richard |
| Rupert | Rudy | Tina |
| Ethan | Tina | Rob M |
|
|
|
| Colby |
|
| Tina |
|
| Jerri |
|
| Rupert | Rudy | Lex |
| Rob M | Rob M |
|
|
|
|
|
| Shii Ann |
| Ethan |
|
| Jerri |
|
| Rupert | Rudy | Lex |
| Rob M |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Shii Ann |
| Sue | Alicia | Amber |
|
| Shii Ann |
|
|
| Shii Ann |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Lex |
|
|
| Richard |
| Rupert | Rudy | Tina |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Rudy |
|
| Jerri |
|
| Jenna L | Lex |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Rupert |
|
| Jerri |
|
| Jenna L |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Amber | Rob M | Tom |
|
| Shii Ann |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Richard |
|
|
| Lex |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Jerri |
|
| Rupert |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Tom | Alicia | Amber |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Alicia | Sue |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|